California fast-food law is blocked for 2023. Voters to decide in 2024
Written by Lucky Wilson | KGTO Writer on December 19, 2022
- A fast-food bill signed into law by California Gov. Newsom in September was to go into effect in January.
- It aimed to raise the minimum wage and improve working conditions for fast-food workers.
- But a million people signed a petition to block it and force it to go to a ballot vote in 2024.
Fast food may remain affordable for at least another year in California, but possibly at the expense of increased wages for the industry’s workers.
AB 257, or the FAST Act, also known as Fast Food Recovery Act, was signed into law by California Gov. Gavin Newsom on Sept. 5 to go into effect in January. Two days later, the FAST Act was met with a voter referendum effort to block the law.
A million signatures and 90 days later, the block proved successful. The law can’t be implemented unless it wins a ballot vote in November 2024.
The FAST Act would give an appointed 10-member state council, or “Fast Food Council,” wide-ranging authority over fast food and fast casual restaurants in California with more than 100 locations nationwide. The council could raise the minimum wage to $22 per hour in 2023 and up to 3.5% annually after that. It could also set minimum standards for working conditions, maximum hours worked, security, and more.
The Service Employees International Union (SEIU) claims the bill gives workers “a seat at the table to help set wage, health, safety, training standards across fast-food industry,” while opponents claim food prices would soar as much as 22%, bringing further hardship to those already suffering under the highest inflation in a generation.
Finding less expensive food:Expired foods get new life from budget shoppers as inflation soars, but are they safe?
Food insecurity:Food banks are struggling this holiday season as inflation creates ‘perfect storm’
How would this fast-food act impact small businesses?
Increased costs ultimately mean fewer small, local restaurants, studies show.
If wages rise to around $22 per hour, labor costs could increase by more than 60% for these businesses, wrote Christopher Thornberg, director of the University of California, Riverside School of Business Center for Economic Forecasting and Development in a study this year supported by the International Franchise Association (IFA).
Wages and inflation:Good news is wages are rising. Unfortunately, that may also be bad news. Here’s why.
Rising pay:Wages are rising fastest in these 9 states. You may be surprised why.
California’s Department of Finance opposed the bill in June, saying it would be expensive to enforce and “could lead to a fragmented regulatory and legal environment for employers and raise long-term costs across industries.” The department also questioned if the bill would even accomplish its goal.
Of 67 economists in an August Employment Policies Institute survey, 93% expect operating costs will rise, 84% said fewer restaurant chains would want to operate in California and 73% said franchisees will close restaurants.
Franchise-focused research firm FRANdata estimates the bill will affect 16,753 franchised locations in California operated by 5,820 franchisees.
Small businesses worry:Holiday shoppers are leery of spending due to inflation. Small business owners are concerned.
Food inflation:Food prices soar amid inflation. How much the cost of eggs, cereal, milk is going up.
How would consumers pay the price?
About 70% of Californians, or 28 million people, eat at quick service restaurants each week. Underrepresented communities, and those who can afford it least, will be hit hardest as businesses pass on higher costs to consumers.
“The measure would establish an unelected council to control labor policy in the counter-service restaurant industry, cause food prices to increase by as much as 20% during a period of decades-high inflation, and harm thousands of small family-, minority-, and women-owned businesses across the state,” Save Local Restaurants, led by the National Restaurant Association, IFA and The U.S. Chamber of Commerce, said in a statement.
For every 20% to 60% increase in wages, Thornberg estimates restaurant prices will rise 7% to 22%. Some IFA members forecast prices could rise more, possibly as much as 40%.
Households with an average annual income of $35,000 would pay an extra $184 per year to maintain their current levels of consumption if wages rose 20%, Thornberg estimates.
Looking for loyalty:Restaurant loyalty programs: Is it worth spending $140 to get a free burrito?
Competing for workers:Rising retail, restaurant, fast-food wages make hiring tougher for manufacturing, construction, health care
Who could the bill hurt?
“If you are a small business owner running two restaurants that are part of a national chain, like McDonald’s, you can be targeted by the bill,” Joe Erlinger, McDonald’s USA president, wrote last summer. “But if you own 20 restaurants that are not part of a large chain, the bill does not apply to you.”
Additionally, many business groups representing minority communities said the law would kill opportunity. “Not only do franchise models provide minority entrepreneurs with uncharted economic opportunity, but the franchise model represents a key pathway towards achieving the American Dream while also generating employment, revenue, and opportunity for their immediate communities,” they said.
Fast-food fight:Hot dog feud: Sam’s Club lowers hot dog combo to $1.38, making it cheaper than rival Costco
Small business growth:Americans began new businesses at record pace in 2021. Here’s how they’re doing.
Who benefits from the bill?
SEIU says California’s 550,000 fast-food workers, most of them Black or Hispanic, would benefit “with a seat at the table to help set minimum industry standards around wages, safety and training.”
The minimum wage in California is $15 an hour. The average fair-market rent for a two-bedroom apartment in the state jumped to $2,274 this year from $1,526 in 2021, according to RentData.org, which provides free rental price data for homes and apartments across the country.
Rent surge:Rents are rising at fastest pace in 40 years. Why it’s bad for inflation, the Fed, and you.
Union walking:Starbucks workers strike across US
But opponents say unions are the main benefactors. Typically, employees at one location must organize with labor unions negotiating for them.
Under the FAST Act, though, unions can skip the organizing and instead go straight to negotiating, Sean Redmond, vice president of Labor Policy at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, said.
“Labor unions and their political allies want to impose a form of sectoral bargaining that runs afoul of American labor policy,” Redmond said.
What happens next?
SEIU is questioning if all million signatures the Save Local Restaurants Coalition collected to block the law are valid.
Assuming the signatures are valid, the bill wouldn’t go into effect until voters have their say in November 2024 whether to adopt such a law.
If the bill passes, SEIU hopes copycat legislation will follow in other states. That would “clearly” have “anti-growth ramifications,” said Andy Barish, Jefferies analyst, in an analyst note in September.
Medora Lee is a money, markets and personal finance reporter at USA TODAY. You can reach her at [email protected] and subscribe to our free Daily Money newsletter for personal finance tips and business news every Monday through Friday morning.
Source link
